Difference between revisions of "PhD Forum"

From MarineLives
Jump to: navigation, search
m
 
(85 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 7: Line 7:
 
'''Purpose of this page'''
 
'''Purpose of this page'''
  
−
This page is entry point into the MarineLives online Project Manual, and is a resource for the members of our newly launched PhD Forum
+
This page is entry point into the MarineLives online Project Manual, and is a resource for the members of our newly launched PhD Forum, as well as existing project members
 
----
 
----
 
__TOC__
 
__TOC__
Line 30: Line 30:
 
[[C17th Arctic whaling|C17th Arctic whaling]]
 
[[C17th Arctic whaling|C17th Arctic whaling]]
 
[[Virginia tobacco trade in the 1650s|Virginia tobacco trade in the 1650s]]
 
[[Virginia tobacco trade in the 1650s|Virginia tobacco trade in the 1650s]]
 +
 +
[[ERC Exeter paper research|ERC Exeter paper research]]
 +
 +
[[Identity|Identity]]
 +
[[Inns, Taverns, and Victualling Houses|Inns, Taverns, and Victualling Houses]]
 +
[[Worth more than hee oweth|Worth more than hee oweth]]
 +
  
 
[[Useful articles and secondary materials|Useful articles and secondary materials]]
 
[[Useful articles and secondary materials|Useful articles and secondary materials]]
Line 48: Line 55:
 
==PhD Forum members and convenors==
 
==PhD Forum members and convenors==
  
−
'''Jamie LeAnne Hager Goodall''' (Ohio State University)
+
'''Richard Blakemore''' (University of Exeter)
  
−
Research subject: Piracy in the C16th and C17th
+
[http://humanities.exeter.ac.uk/history/staff/blakemore/other/ Profile]
−
 
+
−
'''Elin Jones''' (Queen Marys, University of London)
+
−
 
+
−
Research subject: Masculinities and Material Culture in the Royal Navy, 1758-1815
+
−
 
+
−
'''Richard Blakemore''' (University of Exeter)
+
  
 
Research subject: Social history of early modern seafarers, particularly during the seventeenth century. Also interested in questions of vocational identity and authority, popular religion and popular politics in the early modern period, the development of maritime trade, and the history of navigation.
 
Research subject: Social history of early modern seafarers, particularly during the seventeenth century. Also interested in questions of vocational identity and authority, popular religion and popular politics in the early modern period, the development of maritime trade, and the history of navigation.
Line 65: Line 66:
  
 
Research subject: C17th and marine history
 
Research subject: C17th and marine history
 +
 +
'''John Gallagher''' (University of Cambridge)
 +
 +
[http://www.hist.cam.ac.uk/directory/jg545@cam.ac.uk Profile]
 +
 +
Research subject:  Interested in histories of language and communication, and in asking how members of different linguistic communities made themselves understood amid the linguistic ferment of the early modern period. My work is interdisciplinary, bringing approaches from linguistics and from the social sciences to bear on historical sources.
 +
 +
PhD dissertation (in progress) provisionally titled 'The linguistic encounters of English speakers in the early modern world, c. 1483-1730'
 +
 +
'''Jamie LeAnne Hager Goodall''' (Ohio State University)
 +
 +
[http://www.blogger.com/profile/13211731164476304107 Profile]
 +
 +
Research subject: Piracy in the C16th and C17th
  
 
'''Dr Liam Haydon''' (University of Manchester)
 
'''Dr Liam Haydon''' (University of Manchester)
Line 71: Line 86:
  
 
'''Philip Hnatkovich''' (Pennsylvania State University)
 
'''Philip Hnatkovich''' (Pennsylvania State University)
 +
 +
[http://history.psu.edu/directory/pjh206 Profile]
  
 
Research subject: Social history of maritime communities in early modern England and France, with particular interests in maritime industry, production of scientific and technical marine knowledge, and alien communities.
 
Research subject: Social history of maritime communities in early modern England and France, with particular interests in maritime industry, production of scientific and technical marine knowledge, and alien communities.
  
 
Ph.D. dissertation (in progress) on the multinational system of maritime trade, religious activism, and migration among English and French Channel ports during the Tudor-Stuart era, and its impact on early English colonial projects in the Americas.
 
Ph.D. dissertation (in progress) on the multinational system of maritime trade, religious activism, and migration among English and French Channel ports during the Tudor-Stuart era, and its impact on early English colonial projects in the Americas.
 +
 +
'''Elin Jones''' (Queen Marys, University of London)
 +
 +
[http://www.geog.qmul.ac.uk/staff/jonese.html Profile]
 +
 +
Research subject: Masculinities and Material Culture in the Royal Navy, 1758-1815
  
 
'''Sue Jones''' (Birkbeck College, University of London)
 
'''Sue Jones''' (Birkbeck College, University of London)
Line 81: Line 104:
  
 
'''Jennifer Oliver''' (University of Oxford)
 
'''Jennifer Oliver''' (University of Oxford)
 +
 +
[http://www.sjc.ox.ac.uk/375-2949/Fallaize-Fund-Graduate-Scholarship.html Profile]
  
 
Research subject: Ships of state and authorship: exploring national and authorial identity in sixteenth-century France
 
Research subject: Ships of state and authorship: exploring national and authorial identity in sixteenth-century France
  
 
'''Katherine Parker''' (University of Pittsburgh)
 
'''Katherine Parker''' (University of Pittsburgh)
 +
 +
[http://www.history.pitt.edu/graduate/parkerbiopage_000.php Profile]
  
 
Research subject: Creation of geographic knowledge about the Pacific in the eighteenth century, centred on the Royal Navy exploratory expeditions
 
Research subject: Creation of geographic knowledge about the Pacific in the eighteenth century, centred on the Royal Navy exploratory expeditions
 +
 +
'''Dr Cathryn Pearce''' (Greenwich Maritime Institute)
 +
 +
[http://www2.gre.ac.uk/about/schools/gmi/about/staff/dr-cathryn-pearce Profile]
 +
 +
Research subject: Wrecking and plundering shipwrecks; maritime crime including piracy
  
 
'''Margaret Schotte''' (University of Princeton)
 
'''Margaret Schotte''' (University of Princeton)
 +
 +
[http://www.princeton.edu/histgrads/profiles/mschotte/ Profile]
  
 
Research subject: Comparative study of navigational instruction between the late C16th and end of the C18th
 
Research subject: Comparative study of navigational instruction between the late C16th and end of the C18th
  
 
'''Steven Schrum''' (University of Washington, Saint Louis)
 
'''Steven Schrum''' (University of Washington, Saint Louis)
 +
 +
[http://history.artsci.wustl.edu/steve_schrum Profile]
  
 
Research subject: Regulation and the Economic Development of England and the Dutch Republic in the 1690s
 
Research subject: Regulation and the Economic Development of England and the Dutch Republic in the 1690s
Line 101: Line 138:
  
 
'''Royline Williams-Fontenelle''' (University of Oklahoma, Norman)
 
'''Royline Williams-Fontenelle''' (University of Oklahoma, Norman)
 +
 +
[http://cas.ou.edu/royline-n-williams-fontenelle Profile]
  
 
Research subject: Studying how to address the history of West Indian slavery and Technology as co-evolved institutions on the island of Antigua
 
Research subject: Studying how to address the history of West Indian slavery and Technology as co-evolved institutions on the island of Antigua
  
 
----
 
----
−
==Draft PhD Forum schedule of activities==
+
==PhD Forum schedule of activities==
  
 +
<u>W/C 12/11/12</u>
 +
 +
'''Thursday, November 15th'''
 +
 +
* Welcome email to new PhD Forum members
 +
 +
* Assigned Username and Passwords to new PhD Forum members
 +
 +
* Creation of Mediawiki accounts for new PhD Forum members, enabling full access to marineLives-Transcript/SCRIPTO
 +
 +
* Access granted to MarineLives Page Log and Planner for new PhD Forum members
 +
 +
----
 +
'''Friday, November 16th'''
 +
 +
* Creation of an [https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AoNoOr05QRMtdHAyNmxuVnNmYkJ3Q0ZiNEQ0R0V2S3c#gid=1 Occupational analysis worksheet], which is behind the [https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AoNoOr05QRMtdHAyNmxuVnNmYkJ3Q0ZiNEQ0R0V2S3c#gid=0 Page Log] in the online Google Doc Page Log and Planner.  PhD Forum members and associates have access to both documents - any problems, please get in touch with colin.greenstreet@gmail.com.  The worksheet is a first cut of an occupational and status analysis, and contains occupational, age, and location data for a subset of HCA 13/71 witnesses.  Comments, analytical suggestions, and comparative data are welcomed
 +
----
 +
'''Wednesday, November 21st'''
 +
 +
* Welcome to Dr Cathryn Pearce, who is joining the PhD Forum. Cathryn is affiliated to the Greenwich Maritime Institute, where she is an honorary research fellow, and will be teaching a course next year on Maritime crime. Her research and teaching interests include piracy and privateering, with a special interest in wrecking and plundering. She has volunteered to pull together transcribed material from HCA 13/71 relating to piracy and privateering, and is interested in making contact with other members of the Forum exploring similar topics. Cathryn is also a MarineLives associate.
 +
 +
* Creation of two new themes: [[Violence|Violence]] and [[Merchants accounts|Merchants accounts]]
 +
----
 +
'''Sunday, November 25th'''
 +
 +
* Created new theme: [[Textile trade|Textile trade]]
 +
----
 +
'''Tuesday, December 4th'''
 +
 +
* Posting of draft briefing notes on [[PhD Forum briefing note: Material culture and language|PhD Forum briefing note: Material culture and language]] and [[PhD Forum briefing note: Geography and trade; Commerce and law|PhD Forum briefing note: Geography and trade; Commerce and law]]
 +
 +
----
 +
==Draft briefing notes for online sessions==
 +
----
 +
===PhD Forum briefing note: Material culture and language===
 +
 +
[[PhD Forum briefing note: Material culture and language|PhD Forum briefing note: Material culture and language]]
 +
----
 +
===PhD Forum briefing note: Geography and trade; Commerce and law===
 +
 +
[[PhD Forum briefing note: Geography and trade; Commerce and law|PhD Forum briefing note: Geography and trade; Commerce and law]]
 +
----
 +
 +
==Remarkable resilience of a crew on voyage from Virginia to London==
 +
 +
The resilience, courage and luck of some crews plying the Atlantic routes is well illustrated by the following excerpt from the testimony of a twenty-two year old mariner and ship's carpenter from Shadwell. The carpenter, William Welch, had returned to London from Virginia on the King of Poland through terrible winter storms in February 1655(56). The transcription is by Jill Wilcox.<ref>[http://marinelives-transcript.org/scripto/scripto/?scripto_action=transcribe&scripto_doc_id=687&scripto_doc_page_id=708 HCA 13/71 f.249v]; [http://marinelives-transcript.org/scripto/scripto/?scripto_action=transcribe&scripto_doc_id=743&scripto_doc_page_id=709 HCA 13/71 f.250r]</ref>
 +
 +
"1. to the 3: 4th 5th and 6th article of the sayd allegation hee saith that
 +
2. the sayd shipp having soe taken in her sayd ladeing of Tobaccoe
 +
3. at Bermudas and Virginia the arlate ffrederick Johnson and company
 +
4. Mariners of the sayd shipp whereof this deponent was one sett sayle
 +
5. with the sayd shipp and her sayd ladeing of Tobaccoe from James
 +
6. River in Virginia ˹from or about the 27th day of˺ the moneth of January 1655 English
 +
7. style bounds for London and saith that upon or about the first
 +
8. day of ffebruary last in the morning the sayd shipp being with her
 +
9. sayd Lading in her course for London and about the latitude of
 +
10. thirty seaven degrees and a halfe and about ninety leagues to the
 +
11. Eastwards of Virginia was surprized with an exceeding great
 +
12. tempest the winds Blowing at west North west or thereabouts
 +
13. with great furie and the sayd tempest continueing for fower or
 +
14. fives dayes togeather the violence thereof drove in great seas into
 +
15. the sayd shipp which raked her both fore and afte and split
 +
16. and staved her longe boate all to peeces and breake the head of
 +
17. her Rudder short off and soe brake the Iron works thereof that the
 +
18. Rudder hung loose and was in continuall danger to bee wholly
 +
19. torne off and carried away from the sayd shipp and the violence of
 +
20. the sayd storme alsoe broke downe of the the waste of the
 +
21. sayd shipp on both sides and brake some of her timbers and the
 +
22. sea ran violently into the sayd shipps hold and ˹other˺ parts of
 +
23. her and amongst her goods and ladeing of her to the great
 +
24. perill of the lives of the sayd shipps company and eminent
 +
25. danger of the losse of the sayd shipp and goods not withstanding
 +
26. the sayd shipps company did use all possible meanes to
 +
27. preserve them selves their sayd shipp and ladeing and did
 +
28. presently after the sayd Rudder heads and Iron worke was broken
 +
29. hange out men in roapes over the sayd shipps sides side (SIC)
 +
30. to worke and fasten the sayd Rudder againe thereby to bring
 +
31. the sayd shipp to her steerage who with great hazards of
 +
32. their lives did fasten the same but the tempest continueing
 +
33. with great furie presently brake the same and soe that
 +
34. untill about fower dayes after the first beginning of the
 +
35. sayd storme the sayd shipps Rudder could not bee fastened
 +
36. soe as to make it continue fast And the Master and company
 +
37. during the sayd storme were forced to pumpe ˹and did pumped˺ by turnes
 +
38. day and night continually at the chayne pumpe of the sayd
 +
39. shipp and use all other meanes possible to preserve the sayd
 +
40. shipp and ladeing and by Gods blessing upon such their
 +
41. labours did with great difficulty preseve her and her ladeing
 +
42. from sinkeing in the sea by meanes of the sayd storme..."
 +
 +
"1. hee the better knoweth being carpenter of the sayd shipp and one
 +
2. of these that hang out in roapes and workes in great perill about
 +
3. fashioning the sayd Rudder and alsoe helped to work at the pumps
 +
4. and sawe the Master ˹and˺ others of the sayd shipps company worke at the
 +
5. sayd pumps And further to these articles hee cannot depose
 +
6. To the 7th article the sayd allegation hee saith that the sayd first
 +
7. storme being under the sayd shipp in her passage from Virginia
 +
8. to London did about the 9th of the sayd moneth of ffebruary meete
 +
9. with an other very violent storme which continued with great furies
 +
10. till about the 12 th of the same moneth and with some abatement
 +
11. of the violence thereof from the sayd 12th till about the 16th of the
 +
12. sayd moneth, by meanes whereof the sayd shipp being very dammified
 +
13. by the former storme the for shee againe receaved much water into
 +
14. her hold other parts of her and amongst her goods, her decks being
 +
15. unavoidably seldom cleere of water not withstanding the master
 +
16. and company of her afore all possible endeavour to prevent all damage
 +
17. that might happen to her and her lading And but the waste and timbers
 +
18. of the sayd shipp were soe broken with the first stormes and the tyme soe
 +
19. short betweene the sayd two stormes that what was mended after
 +
20. the first storme was broken and spoiled againe by violence of
 +
21. the second storme this hee deposeth for the reasons aforesayd..."
 +
 +
- ''HCA 13/71 f.250r Case: A Busines of Examination of wittnesses on the behalfe of Thomas Allen Anthony Peniston and Company Owners of the shipp the King of Poland whereof ffrederick Johnson is Master) against John Wright Jasper White Perient Trott Thomas Tomlinson John Butts Richard Chandler and George Watermann ("Examined upon an allegation given in and admitted the Eleaventh day of June 1656 on behalfe of the sayd Thomas Allen Anthony Peniston and Company"): Deposition: William Welch of Shadwell in the parish of Stepney and County of Middlesex Mariner Shipwright aged twenty two yeares; Date: ?Between 14 & 17/06/1656''
 
----
 
----
 
==Nascent articles==
 
==Nascent articles==
Line 129: Line 281:
  
 
[[Bound for Barbary|Bound for Barbary]]
 
[[Bound for Barbary|Bound for Barbary]]
 +
[[Brest men of war|Brest men of war]]
 +
[[Commercial law|Commercial law]]
 +
[[Credit|Credit]]
 +
[[Currants and raisins trade|Currants and raisins trade]]
 +
[[Customs and excise|Customs and excise]]
 +
[[Discipline|Discipline]]
 +
[[Dover|Dover]]
 +
[[Dunkirk men of war|Dunkirk men of war]]
 +
[[English coastal trading|English coastal trading]]
 +
[[Dutch merchants in London and elsewhere|Dutch merchants in London and elsewhere]]
 +
[[Factors|Factors]]
 
[[Female involvement in marine activities|Female involvement in marine activities]]
 
[[Female involvement in marine activities|Female involvement in marine activities]]
 +
[[Fish|Fish]]
 +
[[Flemish merchants|Flemish merchants]]
 +
[[French merchants|French merchants]]
 +
[[High Court of Admiralty process|High Court of Admiralty process]]
 
[[Injury and death|Injury and death]]
 
[[Injury and death|Injury and death]]
 +
[[Inns, Taverns, and Victualling Houses|Inns, Taverns, and Victualling Houses]]
 +
[[Bad behaviour & Invective|Bad behaviour & Invective]]
 
[[Jewish merchants|Jewish merchants]]
 
[[Jewish merchants|Jewish merchants]]
 +
[[Language|Language]]
 +
[[London taverns|London taverns]]
 +
[[Market conditions|Market conditions]]
 
[[Maritime incompetence|Maritime incompetence]]
 
[[Maritime incompetence|Maritime incompetence]]
 
[[Masquerade|Masquerade]]
 
[[Masquerade|Masquerade]]
 
[[Materials handling|Materials handling]]
 
[[Materials handling|Materials handling]]
 +
[[Merchants accounts|Merchants accounts]]
 +
[[Metals trade|Metals trade]]
 
[[Navigation|Navigation]]
 
[[Navigation|Navigation]]
 +
[[Oranges and lemons trade|Oranges and lemons trade]]
 +
[[Ostend men of war|Ostend men of war]]
 +
[[Privateering and piracy|Privateering and piracy]]
 
[[Ports|Ports]]
 
[[Ports|Ports]]
 +
[[Portuguese merchants in London|Portuguese merchants in London]]
 
[[Port trades|Port trades]]
 
[[Port trades|Port trades]]
 +
[[Prominent individuals|Prominent individuals]]
 +
[[Salt trade|Salt trade]]
 +
[[Seasonality|Seasonality]]
 
[[Seamens' wages|Seamens' wages]]
 
[[Seamens' wages|Seamens' wages]]
 +
[[Ship economics|Ship economics]]
 +
[[Slave trade|Slave trade]]
 
[[Slavery without redemption|Slavery without redemption]]
 
[[Slavery without redemption|Slavery without redemption]]
 +
[[Spanish merchants in London|Spanish merchants in London]]
 +
[[Swedish and Norwegian merchants|Swedish and Norwegian merchants]]
 +
[[Textile trade|Textile trade]]
 
[[Thames docks and wharves|Thames docks and wharves]]
 
[[Thames docks and wharves|Thames docks and wharves]]
 +
[[Thames estuary|Thames estuary]]
 
[[Thames lighters|Thames lighters]]
 
[[Thames lighters|Thames lighters]]
 
[[Thames shipyards in 1650s|Thames shipyards in 1650s]]
 
[[Thames shipyards in 1650s|Thames shipyards in 1650s]]
 
[[The Exchange in the City of London|The Exchange in the City of London]]
 
[[The Exchange in the City of London|The Exchange in the City of London]]
 +
[[Timber trade|Timber trade]]
 +
[[Violence|Violence]]
 +
[[Wine trade|Wine trade]]
  
 
----
 
----
 
[[Comments]]
 
[[Comments]]
 +
----
 +
''2012-11-16 07:07:31'' [[nbsp]] Welcome to John Gallagher, University of Cambridge, who is joining the MarineLives PhD Forum.  John is a PhD student at Emmanuel College Cambridge, with research interests in language and communication in the Early Modern world --[[Users/ColinGreenstreet|Users/ColinGreenstreet]]
 +
------
 +
''2012-11-16 10:45:05'' [[nbsp]] Check out some rough cut occupational and status analysis for the first 65 folios of HCA 13/71. In ff.1r-63v twice as many mariners as merchants deposed as witnesses.  See [[Semantic Markup General#head-6b1c2b90f79fe9d577cc32dab2c70c27dc5cd43f|Occupational and social status analysis of witnesses in HCA 13/71]]
 +
 +
You can look also look at the age data and occupation data for the different occupation and status groups
 +
 +
A full analysis to follow within the next couple of days --[[Users/ColinGreenstreet|Users/ColinGreenstreet]]
 +
------
 +
''2012-11-16 16:39:35'' [[nbsp]] There is now an [https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AoNoOr05QRMtdHAyNmxuVnNmYkJ3Q0ZiNEQ0R0V2S3c#gid=1 Occupational analysis worksheet], which is behind the [https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0AoNoOr05QRMtdHAyNmxuVnNmYkJ3Q0ZiNEQ0R0V2S3c#gid=0 Page Log] in the online Google Doc Page Log and Planner you all have access to.
 +
 +
You might want to check out the latest version of this occupational analysis sheet. Data are in for f.1r to f.154v (so about 22% of total). There is double counting, which I will strip out by consolidiating individuals and allowing multiple columns to code for status, occupation, and job title. Nevertheless, I am surprised at how old some of the mariners are, and not just the captains, masters and commanders of ships.
 +
 +
The literacy analysis is very incomplete, since I have only currently captured signature vs marke for a relatively small number of the depositions, and someone will have to go back to all the images/transcriptions at the appropriate folio (we know where each deposition finishes, so it is not all 674 folios, and capture all the data onto the Page Log sheet.
 +
 +
Nevethless there is a high degree of basic literacy amongst mariners. Only a relatively small proportion of English mariners (often provincially based), and perhaps a higher portion of marine tradesmen and suppliers (shipwrights, coopers, butchers, watermen, labourers, and quite a high proportion of non-English mariners really having to leave their mark in the sample analysed to date.
 +
 +
'''You can explore the raw data yourself in the online Page Log. Use the Column J filter in the Page Log to look at signatures and markes, and the Columns K to M filters to look at occupation.'''
 +
 +
'''You can explore the sample of analysed data by using column filters for surname (Colimn B), age (Column C), literacy (Column D), occupation and/or status description (Column E), and five levels of location (street and building level, if available: Column G; parish level, if available: Column H; village, town or city: Column I; county or province: Column J; country: Column K). The raw data from which this is coded is reproduced in Column L).  The underlying images for any case can be accessed through the URLs for the appropriate deposition in the Page Log.'''
 +
 +
Does anyone know of comparative data that exist for C16th, C17th and C18th by occupational group with a marine flavour, inclduing port trades?  We will later be able to look at basic literacy rates for captains/masters/commanders vs other officers vs non-officers --[[Users/ColinGreenstreet|Users/ColinGreenstreet]]
 +
------
 +
''2012-11-17 13:55:26'' [[nbsp]] Verbal and physical violence are a feature of a fair number of depositions.  But it is rare for a ship to be lost as a result.  But this was the allegation made by the gunner of the Fortune, who observed:
 +
 +
"the sayd Braining the Master without any provocation given him fell in furious manner upon the Boatswayn of the sayd shipp and with a stick or Cudgell knockt him on the head and wounded him very sore, to the endangereing of his life so as he became unable to give any assistance when the shipp was in danger"
 +
 +
See the new theme [[Violence|Violence]] and add your own contributions and comments. --[[Users/ColinGreenstreet|Users/ColinGreenstreet]]
 +
------
 +
''2012-11-19 14:34:55'' [[nbsp]] I don't know if this is the best place to post this - it links to occupational and social status, I couldn't find a comment option there (showing the extent of my computer expertise...) but I can offer some comparative comments from my own research.
 +
 +
Vincent Patarino, in an article on 'religious shipboard culture', published in Fury, ed., The social history of English seamen (2012) (http://www.boydellandbrewer.com/store/viewItem.asp?idProduct=13786) has some figures across the seventeenth century, sampled from five files (HCA 1/9, 1/101, 13/64, 13/97 and 12/142), showing 37% of sailors and 63% of officers signing in 1603-30s, 93.6% of officers and 76.2% of sailors in 1650s-70s. In my own research, I have figures from the 1640s (HCA 13/56-61), pertaining only to London seafarers. 62-79% of these mariners, 87-94% of commanding officers, and 64-76% of other officers were signing their names (these represent the range of percentages from individual volumes). Literacy in London was probably higher than average, given the figures in David Cressy, Literacy and the social order (1980).
 +
 +
On age, I too was surprised to see how old a number of seafarers were, but I suspect this reflects the tendency for older and more experienced seafarers and officers to appear as deponents. From the same volumes, for London seafarers, only 40 per cent of deponents were under thirty; but over half of the sample were officers of some kind. This compares with a survey of London seafarers from 1629 in the state papers (SP 16/135, fos 111r-27v), in which only one third were officers and 56 per cent of all in the survey were under thirty. Unsurprisingly, the HCA are not a perfect census, although it does seem they are not actually that far out.
 +
 +
I think this raises two interesting points - firstly, how useful the HCA papers are for recovering details about early modern seafarers; and secondly, how careful we have to be about legal sources and whether they are truly representative. --[[Users/richardblakemore|Users/richardblakemore]]

Latest revision as of 10:35, November 25, 2013

PhD Forum

Editorial history

23/08/12: CSG, created page


Purpose of this page

This page is entry point into the MarineLives online Project Manual, and is a resource for the members of our newly launched PhD Forum, as well as existing project members




Suggested links


Project Goals
Colin's Page

Online Training Activities
Introduction to the High Court of Admiralty

MarineLives Transcription & Editorial Policy: Draft Five
Semantic markup policy: Version One

Terms and Dictionaries

-Geographical and Place Terms
-Marine Terms
-Commodities

C17th Arctic whaling
Virginia tobacco trade in the 1650s

ERC Exeter paper research

Identity
Inns, Taverns, and Victualling Houses
Worth more than hee oweth


Useful articles and secondary materials

Creating a wiki Page
Searching the Wiki
Editing a Wiki Page
Inserting and Editing Text
Cropping and Inserting images

Full wiki index

MarineLives TRANSCRIPT
The Shipping News
MarineLives website


PhD Forum members and convenors


Richard Blakemore (University of Exeter)

Profile

Research subject: Social history of early modern seafarers, particularly during the seventeenth century. Also interested in questions of vocational identity and authority, popular religion and popular politics in the early modern period, the development of maritime trade, and the history of navigation.

Recently submitted Ph.D. dissertation is a study of London seafarers, maritime tradesmen, and their families during the British civil wars, exploring how, and to what extent, their actions in and experiences of the 1640s were shaped by a shared occupational identity, based upon the cultural stereotype of the ‘seaman’, and what impact the civil wars had upon them as a community

Dr Janet Few (PhD, University of Exeter)

Research subject: C17th and marine history

John Gallagher (University of Cambridge)

Profile

Research subject: Interested in histories of language and communication, and in asking how members of different linguistic communities made themselves understood amid the linguistic ferment of the early modern period. My work is interdisciplinary, bringing approaches from linguistics and from the social sciences to bear on historical sources.

PhD dissertation (in progress) provisionally titled 'The linguistic encounters of English speakers in the early modern world, c. 1483-1730'

Jamie LeAnne Hager Goodall (Ohio State University)

Profile

Research subject: Piracy in the C16th and C17th

Dr Liam Haydon (University of Manchester)

Research subject: Links between commercial and literary production; Milton

Philip Hnatkovich (Pennsylvania State University)

Profile

Research subject: Social history of maritime communities in early modern England and France, with particular interests in maritime industry, production of scientific and technical marine knowledge, and alien communities.

Ph.D. dissertation (in progress) on the multinational system of maritime trade, religious activism, and migration among English and French Channel ports during the Tudor-Stuart era, and its impact on early English colonial projects in the Americas.

Elin Jones (Queen Marys, University of London)

Profile

Research subject: Masculinities and Material Culture in the Royal Navy, 1758-1815

Sue Jones (Birkbeck College, University of London)

Research subject: Research into early modern literature about pirates, looking in particular at utopian ideas, space and mobility

Jennifer Oliver (University of Oxford)

Profile

Research subject: Ships of state and authorship: exploring national and authorial identity in sixteenth-century France

Katherine Parker (University of Pittsburgh)

Profile

Research subject: Creation of geographic knowledge about the Pacific in the eighteenth century, centred on the Royal Navy exploratory expeditions

Dr Cathryn Pearce (Greenwich Maritime Institute)

Profile

Research subject: Wrecking and plundering shipwrecks; maritime crime including piracy

Margaret Schotte (University of Princeton)

Profile

Research subject: Comparative study of navigational instruction between the late C16th and end of the C18th

Steven Schrum (University of Washington, Saint Louis)

Profile

Research subject: Regulation and the Economic Development of England and the Dutch Republic in the 1690s

Laura Seymour (Birkbeck College, University of London)

Research subject: Research deals with the way in which material spaces can contain and convey information, focussing in particular on gesture. See Hungry Work, an article on the Marine Live's project blog - The Shipping News.

Royline Williams-Fontenelle (University of Oklahoma, Norman)

Profile

Research subject: Studying how to address the history of West Indian slavery and Technology as co-evolved institutions on the island of Antigua


PhD Forum schedule of activities


W/C 12/11/12

Thursday, November 15th

  • Welcome email to new PhD Forum members


  • Assigned Username and Passwords to new PhD Forum members


  • Creation of Mediawiki accounts for new PhD Forum members, enabling full access to marineLives-Transcript/SCRIPTO


  • Access granted to MarineLives Page Log and Planner for new PhD Forum members



Friday, November 16th

  • Creation of an Occupational analysis worksheet, which is behind the Page Log in the online Google Doc Page Log and Planner. PhD Forum members and associates have access to both documents - any problems, please get in touch with colin.greenstreet@gmail.com. The worksheet is a first cut of an occupational and status analysis, and contains occupational, age, and location data for a subset of HCA 13/71 witnesses. Comments, analytical suggestions, and comparative data are welcomed

Wednesday, November 21st

  • Welcome to Dr Cathryn Pearce, who is joining the PhD Forum. Cathryn is affiliated to the Greenwich Maritime Institute, where she is an honorary research fellow, and will be teaching a course next year on Maritime crime. Her research and teaching interests include piracy and privateering, with a special interest in wrecking and plundering. She has volunteered to pull together transcribed material from HCA 13/71 relating to piracy and privateering, and is interested in making contact with other members of the Forum exploring similar topics. Cathryn is also a MarineLives associate.



Sunday, November 25th


Tuesday, December 4th



Draft briefing notes for online sessions


PhD Forum briefing note: Material culture and language


PhD Forum briefing note: Material culture and language


PhD Forum briefing note: Geography and trade; Commerce and law


PhD Forum briefing note: Geography and trade; Commerce and law

Remarkable resilience of a crew on voyage from Virginia to London


The resilience, courage and luck of some crews plying the Atlantic routes is well illustrated by the following excerpt from the testimony of a twenty-two year old mariner and ship's carpenter from Shadwell. The carpenter, William Welch, had returned to London from Virginia on the King of Poland through terrible winter storms in February 1655(56). The transcription is by Jill Wilcox.[1]

"1. to the 3: 4th 5th and 6th article of the sayd allegation hee saith that
2. the sayd shipp having soe taken in her sayd ladeing of Tobaccoe
3. at Bermudas and Virginia the arlate ffrederick Johnson and company
4. Mariners of the sayd shipp whereof this deponent was one sett sayle
5. with the sayd shipp and her sayd ladeing of Tobaccoe from James
6. River in Virginia ˹from or about the 27th day of˺ the moneth of January 1655 English
7. style bounds for London and saith that upon or about the first
8. day of ffebruary last in the morning the sayd shipp being with her
9. sayd Lading in her course for London and about the latitude of
10. thirty seaven degrees and a halfe and about ninety leagues to the
11. Eastwards of Virginia was surprized with an exceeding great
12. tempest the winds Blowing at west North west or thereabouts
13. with great furie and the sayd tempest continueing for fower or
14. fives dayes togeather the violence thereof drove in great seas into
15. the sayd shipp which raked her both fore and afte and split
16. and staved her longe boate all to peeces and breake the head of
17. her Rudder short off and soe brake the Iron works thereof that the
18. Rudder hung loose and was in continuall danger to bee wholly
19. torne off and carried away from the sayd shipp and the violence of
20. the sayd storme alsoe broke downe of the the waste of the
21. sayd shipp on both sides and brake some of her timbers and the
22. sea ran violently into the sayd shipps hold and ˹other˺ parts of
23. her and amongst her goods and ladeing of her to the great
24. perill of the lives of the sayd shipps company and eminent
25. danger of the losse of the sayd shipp and goods not withstanding
26. the sayd shipps company did use all possible meanes to
27. preserve them selves their sayd shipp and ladeing and did
28. presently after the sayd Rudder heads and Iron worke was broken
29. hange out men in roapes over the sayd shipps sides side (SIC)
30. to worke and fasten the sayd Rudder againe thereby to bring
31. the sayd shipp to her steerage who with great hazards of
32. their lives did fasten the same but the tempest continueing
33. with great furie presently brake the same and soe that
34. untill about fower dayes after the first beginning of the
35. sayd storme the sayd shipps Rudder could not bee fastened
36. soe as to make it continue fast And the Master and company
37. during the sayd storme were forced to pumpe ˹and did pumped˺ by turnes
38. day and night continually at the chayne pumpe of the sayd
39. shipp and use all other meanes possible to preserve the sayd
40. shipp and ladeing and by Gods blessing upon such their
41. labours did with great difficulty preseve her and her ladeing
42. from sinkeing in the sea by meanes of the sayd storme..."

"1. hee the better knoweth being carpenter of the sayd shipp and one
2. of these that hang out in roapes and workes in great perill about
3. fashioning the sayd Rudder and alsoe helped to work at the pumps
4. and sawe the Master ˹and˺ others of the sayd shipps company worke at the
5. sayd pumps And further to these articles hee cannot depose
6. To the 7th article the sayd allegation hee saith that the sayd first
7. storme being under the sayd shipp in her passage from Virginia
8. to London did about the 9th of the sayd moneth of ffebruary meete
9. with an other very violent storme which continued with great furies
10. till about the 12 th of the same moneth and with some abatement
11. of the violence thereof from the sayd 12th till about the 16th of the
12. sayd moneth, by meanes whereof the sayd shipp being very dammified
13. by the former storme the for shee againe receaved much water into
14. her hold other parts of her and amongst her goods, her decks being
15. unavoidably seldom cleere of water not withstanding the master
16. and company of her afore all possible endeavour to prevent all damage
17. that might happen to her and her lading And but the waste and timbers
18. of the sayd shipp were soe broken with the first stormes and the tyme soe
19. short betweene the sayd two stormes that what was mended after
20. the first storme was broken and spoiled againe by violence of
21. the second storme this hee deposeth for the reasons aforesayd..."

- HCA 13/71 f.250r Case: A Busines of Examination of wittnesses on the behalfe of Thomas Allen Anthony Peniston and Company Owners of the shipp the King of Poland whereof ffrederick Johnson is Master) against John Wright Jasper White Perient Trott Thomas Tomlinson John Butts Richard Chandler and George Watermann ("Examined upon an allegation given in and admitted the Eleaventh day of June 1656 on behalfe of the sayd Thomas Allen Anthony Peniston and Company"): Deposition: William Welch of Shadwell in the parish of Stepney and County of Middlesex Mariner Shipwright aged twenty two yeares; Date: ?Between 14 & 17/06/1656


Nascent articles


PhD Forum members are invited to look at the MarineLives project exploration of C17th Arctic whaling, taking Batson and others con Gosling and others (1656 and 1657) as the starting point.

An article is being developed by several team members looking at the social structure of one of the whaling ships mentioned in this case, and the network of commercial and financial contacts supporting it. The project team is at the early stage of exploring the potential for something similar on the Virginia tobacco trade in the 1650s.

PhD Forum members are encouraged to contribute to either of these topics, and to explore the growing corpus of HCA 13/71 transcriptions for themes which might be suitable for further articles. All contributions will be acknowledged.

C17th Arctic whaling
Virginia tobacco trade in the 1650s


Themes


The following topics are currently being explored by the MarineLives project team in parallel with transcription work.

Each link will take you to a page which will introduce a topic and list a set of potential references in HCA 13/71, giving the title of the case and deposition, as well as a reference number. Electronic links are being added which will take you directly to the relevant transcription and manuscript image in MarineLives-Transcript/Scripto.

You are invited to explore these themes and to add your own comments and references as you browse HCA 13/71 online. You are also welcome to add your suggestions as to other relevant primary and secondary material, with the focus being on the 1650s.

Bound for Barbary
Brest men of war
Commercial law
Credit
Currants and raisins trade
Customs and excise
Discipline
Dover
Dunkirk men of war
English coastal trading
Dutch merchants in London and elsewhere
Factors
Female involvement in marine activities
Fish
Flemish merchants
French merchants
High Court of Admiralty process
Injury and death
Inns, Taverns, and Victualling Houses
Bad behaviour & Invective
Jewish merchants
Language
London taverns
Market conditions
Maritime incompetence
Masquerade
Materials handling
Merchants accounts
Metals trade
Navigation
Oranges and lemons trade
Ostend men of war
Privateering and piracy
Ports
Portuguese merchants in London
Port trades
Prominent individuals
Salt trade
Seasonality
Seamens' wages
Ship economics
Slave trade
Slavery without redemption
Spanish merchants in London
Swedish and Norwegian merchants
Textile trade
Thames docks and wharves
Thames estuary
Thames lighters
Thames shipyards in 1650s
The Exchange in the City of London
Timber trade
Violence
Wine trade


Comments


2012-11-16 07:07:31 nbsp Welcome to John Gallagher, University of Cambridge, who is joining the MarineLives PhD Forum. John is a PhD student at Emmanuel College Cambridge, with research interests in language and communication in the Early Modern world --Users/ColinGreenstreet


2012-11-16 10:45:05 nbsp Check out some rough cut occupational and status analysis for the first 65 folios of HCA 13/71. In ff.1r-63v twice as many mariners as merchants deposed as witnesses. See Occupational and social status analysis of witnesses in HCA 13/71

You can look also look at the age data and occupation data for the different occupation and status groups

A full analysis to follow within the next couple of days --Users/ColinGreenstreet


2012-11-16 16:39:35 nbsp There is now an Occupational analysis worksheet, which is behind the Page Log in the online Google Doc Page Log and Planner you all have access to.

You might want to check out the latest version of this occupational analysis sheet. Data are in for f.1r to f.154v (so about 22% of total). There is double counting, which I will strip out by consolidiating individuals and allowing multiple columns to code for status, occupation, and job title. Nevertheless, I am surprised at how old some of the mariners are, and not just the captains, masters and commanders of ships.

The literacy analysis is very incomplete, since I have only currently captured signature vs marke for a relatively small number of the depositions, and someone will have to go back to all the images/transcriptions at the appropriate folio (we know where each deposition finishes, so it is not all 674 folios, and capture all the data onto the Page Log sheet.

Nevethless there is a high degree of basic literacy amongst mariners. Only a relatively small proportion of English mariners (often provincially based), and perhaps a higher portion of marine tradesmen and suppliers (shipwrights, coopers, butchers, watermen, labourers, and quite a high proportion of non-English mariners really having to leave their mark in the sample analysed to date.

You can explore the raw data yourself in the online Page Log. Use the Column J filter in the Page Log to look at signatures and markes, and the Columns K to M filters to look at occupation.

You can explore the sample of analysed data by using column filters for surname (Colimn B), age (Column C), literacy (Column D), occupation and/or status description (Column E), and five levels of location (street and building level, if available: Column G; parish level, if available: Column H; village, town or city: Column I; county or province: Column J; country: Column K). The raw data from which this is coded is reproduced in Column L). The underlying images for any case can be accessed through the URLs for the appropriate deposition in the Page Log.

Does anyone know of comparative data that exist for C16th, C17th and C18th by occupational group with a marine flavour, inclduing port trades? We will later be able to look at basic literacy rates for captains/masters/commanders vs other officers vs non-officers --Users/ColinGreenstreet


2012-11-17 13:55:26 nbsp Verbal and physical violence are a feature of a fair number of depositions. But it is rare for a ship to be lost as a result. But this was the allegation made by the gunner of the Fortune, who observed:

"the sayd Braining the Master without any provocation given him fell in furious manner upon the Boatswayn of the sayd shipp and with a stick or Cudgell knockt him on the head and wounded him very sore, to the endangereing of his life so as he became unable to give any assistance when the shipp was in danger"

See the new theme Violence and add your own contributions and comments. --Users/ColinGreenstreet


2012-11-19 14:34:55 nbsp I don't know if this is the best place to post this - it links to occupational and social status, I couldn't find a comment option there (showing the extent of my computer expertise...) but I can offer some comparative comments from my own research.

Vincent Patarino, in an article on 'religious shipboard culture', published in Fury, ed., The social history of English seamen (2012) (http://www.boydellandbrewer.com/store/viewItem.asp?idProduct=13786) has some figures across the seventeenth century, sampled from five files (HCA 1/9, 1/101, 13/64, 13/97 and 12/142), showing 37% of sailors and 63% of officers signing in 1603-30s, 93.6% of officers and 76.2% of sailors in 1650s-70s. In my own research, I have figures from the 1640s (HCA 13/56-61), pertaining only to London seafarers. 62-79% of these mariners, 87-94% of commanding officers, and 64-76% of other officers were signing their names (these represent the range of percentages from individual volumes). Literacy in London was probably higher than average, given the figures in David Cressy, Literacy and the social order (1980).

On age, I too was surprised to see how old a number of seafarers were, but I suspect this reflects the tendency for older and more experienced seafarers and officers to appear as deponents. From the same volumes, for London seafarers, only 40 per cent of deponents were under thirty; but over half of the sample were officers of some kind. This compares with a survey of London seafarers from 1629 in the state papers (SP 16/135, fos 111r-27v), in which only one third were officers and 56 per cent of all in the survey were under thirty. Unsurprisingly, the HCA are not a perfect census, although it does seem they are not actually that far out.

I think this raises two interesting points - firstly, how useful the HCA papers are for recovering details about early modern seafarers; and secondly, how careful we have to be about legal sources and whether they are truly representative. --Users/richardblakemore
  1. ↑ HCA 13/71 f.249v; HCA 13/71 f.250r

Retrieved from ‘http://www.marinelives.org/index.php?title=PhD_Forum&oldid=73439’